Don't Tell Mama NYC

4.3
1637 recensioni
icon/ic_price_rangeCreated with Sketch.
Fino a $30
icon/ic_cuisineCreated with Sketch.
Americana contemporanea
I tag più utilizzati:
  • Prima o dopo il teatro
  • Adatto per un appuntamento
  • Casual

Offerte speciali

prix fixe $42

3 course meal. appetizer, entree and dessert

Termini e condizioni:

Valido per: 1 - 20 persona/e

Inizia: 7 marzo 2019

Termina: 8 marzo 2118

Disponibilità: ven-sab 16:00-23:00

Prix Fixe Menu $38

3 course meal. appetizer, entree and dessert

Termini e condizioni:

Valido per: 1 - 20 persona/e

Inizia: 7 marzo 2019

Termina: 8 marzo 2118

Disponibilità: dom-gio 16:00-22:45

New Year's Eve 4 course prixe fixe - $75

4 course meal plus a complementary flute of champagne

Termini e condizioni:

Valido per: 1 - 20 persona/e

Inizia: 13 dicembre 2018

Termina: 14 dicembre 2117

Disponibilità: lun 19:00-23:00

New Years Eve in Restaurant

4 course Prixe fixe meal for $55

Termini e condizioni:

Valido per: 1 - 20 persona/e

Inizia: 13 dicembre 2018

Termina: 14 dicembre 2117

Disponibilità: lun-mar 16:00-19:00

Christmas Eve and Christmas Day- $45 Prixe Fixe

4 course meal

Termini e condizioni:

Valido per: 1 - 20 persona/e

Inizia: 13 dicembre 2018

Termina: 14 dicembre 2117

Disponibilità: lun-mar 16:00-22:45

Aumenta immediatamente i tuoi punti ricompensa

Vedi disponibilità di tavoli con punti bonus

Mon - Thu 16:00 - 17:00

Cosa dicono 1637 persone
Valutazione complessiva e recensioni
Le recensioni possono essere scritte solo da utenti che hanno visitato questo ristorante
4.3basato sulle recenti valutazioni
4.2
cibo
4.5
servizio
4.3
Atmosfera
4.2
Rapporto qualità-prezzo
Rumorosità · Moderata
Il 91% delle persone lo consiglierebbe ad un amico
5
4
3
2
1
Ordina per
Più recente
Filtri
JH
New York
1 recensione
Visitato 4 giorni fa
Complessivo 2cibo 4servizio 4Atmosfera 3

Having been here on three previous occasions and always having a great time this time very disappointed. The food was good but the guy who rushed in to “perform” was awful.. he was self indulgent and loud .. not a good experience!

Segnala
Utile
w
Chicago
13 recensioni
Visitato 6 giorni fa
Complessivo 4cibo 4servizio 5Atmosfera 4

Pre theater

Segnala
Utile
B
New York
12 recensioni
Visitato 6 giorni fa
Complessivo 5cibo 5servizio 5Atmosfera 4

My newest go to theatre district restaurant. Their prefix meals are always delicious with enough choices for any taste buds. The service is excellent and always friendly.

Segnala
Utile
TF
New York
5 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 10 marzo 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 5servizio 5Atmosfera 5

We went here because the reviews were excellent. We expected a big crowd but we were the only diners on a Sunday at 5pm. That worried me but I can tell you staying was the best thing!! The waiter explained Sunday’s are not consistent. I don’t know why. In my opinion they should be full every day!! Excellent service and food!! I was with my mama so she knows, wink.

Segnala
Utile
K
Baltimora
5 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 10 marzo 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 5servizio 5Atmosfera 5

Thoroughly enjoyed lunch prior to attending Broadway show. Highly recommend this gem, piano singing atmosphere was just perfect.

Segnala
Utile
OT
New York
1 recensione
Visitato il giorno 9 marzo 2019
Complessivo 3cibo 3servizio 5Atmosfera 4

Service was excellent, food was mediocre! Not awful, but just ok.

Segnala
Utile
J
New York
32 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 9 marzo 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 5servizio 5Atmosfera 4

Very good food and the service from Ryan, our server, was exceptional. Would definitely recommend this establishment.

Segnala
Utile
S
1 recensione
Visitato il giorno 6 marzo 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 5servizio 5Atmosfera 4

I stopped in for dinner before a show. I had the braised short ribs. It was served without bones and came with mashed potatoes and mixed vegetables which were cut like speghetti and buttered. There was a thick hearty gravy. Meat was tender and everything was delicious. The portions was large. The service was exemplary. There is a very nice piano bar where I had an after dinner drink. I will be back the next time I am in NYC. This is a very nice place and I defintely recommend this restaurant.

Segnala
Utile
SO
New York
1 recensione
Visitato il giorno 3 marzo 2019
Complessivo 2cibo 3servizio 3Atmosfera 1

Food just so so

Place was empty

Way better choices for food in theater district

Segnala
Utile
j
Surrey
44 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 22 febbraio 2019
Complessivo 4cibo 4servizio 5Atmosfera 5

For a casual night out this was a lovely restaurant. We didn't see the comedy etc just popped in for a meal. I am wheat and dairy free and they were very helpful to accommodate my needs.

The only annoying thing was the door from the restaurant to the club was in constant use and right by our table.

Segnala
Utile
SA
1 recensione
Visitato il giorno 21 febbraio 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 4servizio 5Atmosfera 4

Had a lovely time here was recommended to us , thanks for welcoming us and letting my daughter Charlotte sing . The staff were amazing and very friendly too .

Segnala
Utile
MA
New York
1 recensione
Visitato il giorno 21 febbraio 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 5servizio 5Atmosfera 4

Consistently good food and great service - A great place to go before a show!

Segnala
Utile
HK
Los Angeles
10 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 19 febbraio 2019
Complessivo 1cibo 1servizio 1Atmosfera 1

The nightclub looks like it would be fun but we were there for dinner before a show. The service was pathetic -- our server had no idea what dishes they offered or how they were done. She was in no hurry to get us drinks, or water or even our food. The price for what we had was reflective of the neighborhood, not the cuisine.

Segnala
Utile
MB
1 recensione
Visitato il giorno 17 febbraio 2019
Complessivo 4cibo 4servizio 4Atmosfera 3

Seating was tight. Had 3 course meal from price fix menu ($32 pp). The meal was good, not great, but worth the value, Drinks were NYC pricy $11 for wine $13 for liquor, so bill was almost double of the price fix. The service was good, not overly attentive. Due to tight space it got rather loud.

Segnala
Utile
F
New York
34 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 17 febbraio 2019
Complessivo 3cibo 4servizio 4Atmosfera 2

It was ok. Maybe the ambiance would be a little better if it's cleaner.

Segnala
Utile
MR
1 recensione
Visitato il giorno 16 febbraio 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 5servizio 5Atmosfera 5

This place was awesome. I purposed to my girlfriend here the staff helped out in playing her favourite song on the piano bar which was amazing, great atmosphere and the manager and staff where great. Food was really nice couldnt reccomend this place enough.

Segnala
Utile
OT
1 recensione
Visitato il giorno 14 febbraio 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 5servizio 5Atmosfera 5

Valentine’s Day

Segnala
Utile
B
Birmingham
5 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 11 febbraio 2019
Complessivo 4cibo 4servizio 5Atmosfera 3

Fun gathering with friends. Good food and wine. Outstanding service! Highly recommend.

Segnala
Utile
BF
New York
3 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 9 febbraio 2019
Complessivo 4cibo 5servizio 5Atmosfera 5

Place is small but quaint and pleasant. Food, drinks, and service were excellent. Recommend for pre-theater or any occasion as long as group is 4 or less.

Segnala
Utile
MK
New York
75 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 7 febbraio 2019
Complessivo 3cibo 3servizio 4Atmosfera 3

My meal was satisfactory, if pricey. The service was warm and also satisfactory. The location is perfect for pre-theatre dining.

However, I'm currently debating with Open Table because I should've been credited with 1000 points (as was the offer when I made my online reservation), but only got 100 points. I don't know why this discrepancy happened, but it has tarnished my view of the restaurant, as well as of Open Table...

Segnala
Utile
OT
1 recensione
Visitato il giorno 6 febbraio 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 4servizio 5Atmosfera 5

Great service! Lamb was delicious, steak was more cooked than I ordered it but still tasty.

Segnala
Utile
PC
New York
43 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 3 febbraio 2019
Complessivo 3cibo 3servizio 4Atmosfera 4

I came here for an early dinner between the Harry Potter plays on Sunday, and was seated promptly although I arrived a little early for my reservation. I had the mixed salad, BBQ spare rib and the lemon meringue pie with coffee. Food was fine and the service was very professional. Since only 1 or 2 other tables were occupied at time, the place was quiet. This is a handy place for bite if you are attending the theatre nearby.

Segnala
Utile
F
New York
8 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 27 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 3servizio 4Atmosfera 5

We had a wonderful time again at Don’t Tell Mama. My salmon portion was very small. I felt they should have picked a bigger piece or maybe even combined 2 pieces since they were so small.
But it was delicious. Our waiter was great. We had a lovely dinner.

Segnala
Utile
KS
New York
30 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 26 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 4cibo 4servizio 4Atmosfera 4

Warm, very busy atmosphere. Waiter was nice but had lot of responsibilities to deal with. Food was very tasty, presented nicely and arrived warm! Would return!

Segnala
Utile
OT
1 recensione
Visitato il giorno 25 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 4cibo 5servizio 4Atmosfera 2

The food was great — the service was okay — it was very noisy, difficult to have normal conversation. The piano bar was awesome....

I would come again.

Segnala
Utile
T
Miami
25 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 24 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 3cibo 3servizio 4Atmosfera 3

Great location right off Broadway. A fun atmosphere, good service and good food. Given the choices of restaurants in the area, I would probably not return and would try somewhere new.

Segnala
Utile
AJ
Chicago
43 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 23 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 5servizio 5Atmosfera 4

We loved dinner at Don't Tell Mama. My salad and Shrimp Scampi were outstanding, and there were ample wine choices -- we loved the pinot noir we ended up with. Service was friendly and prompt. We would definitely go back.

Segnala
Utile
J
New York
31 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 22 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 1cibo 2servizio 5Atmosfera 1

The food was just okay and the portions were small. The best part of the meal was dessert.
It is a small room and there was a family of 14 with small children. The noise level was impossible and we ate as fast as we could to get out of there. I understand that is not the fault of the restaurant but they should let patrons know when they book that kind of group. Other than that group and two tables it was empty. I will not be returning. The staff was very nice but could not overcome the noise and the food.

Segnala
Utile
OT
New England
1 recensione
Visitato il giorno 20 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 4servizio 5Atmosfera 4

The service was great, as we were running late before a show and needed to rush a little bit! Our server made sure everything came out quickly, without feeling rushed, and we still made it to the theater with plenty of time to spare! The food was tasty, the restaurant was quiet, especially for a Sunday night. Overall, great experience

Segnala
Utile
D
New York
4 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 20 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 4cibo 4servizio 4Atmosfera 4

Thoroughly enjoyed our experience for four at Don't Tell Mama NYC. Duck with couscous was delicious! Drinks were bigger and cheaper in restaurant than at bar. Wait in piano lounge was cramped, but nice music. Restaurant is small, so seating is close. The staff was super friendly and accommodating. Overall, nice evening.

Segnala
Utile
JK
1 recensione
Visitato il giorno 20 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 4cibo 4servizio 5Atmosfera 4

Excellent food and service! Hidden gem for theatre-goers.

Segnala
Utile
LS
Los Angeles
21 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 19 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 5servizio 5Atmosfera 5

I would eat here every night if i could. Food was amazing. I would have never found it, if not for open table. Everything was awesome!!

Segnala
Utile
j
Washington DC
37 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 19 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 3cibo 4servizio 2Atmosfera 3

The food was fine but the service and speed were pretty bad. We had to ask for everything. From water, to bread, to another drink. It was very frustrating. It appeared they were understaffed. We made our reservation for 6 and I had to take my dessert to go since we had an 8:00 show.
My salmon was tasty. The lamb chops were very good too. You just have to be prepared to wait or give yourself a lot of extra time.

Segnala
Utile
OT
1 recensione
Visitato il giorno 18 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 3cibo 3servizio 5Atmosfera 4

We had a great server. Service was very prompt. Food was good, but nothing special.

Segnala
Utile
SK
New York
3 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 16 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 5servizio 5Atmosfera 5

Service was excellent! Beef short ribs were delicious. Would go again in a heartbeat.

Segnala
Utile
LG
Orange County
8 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 12 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 5servizio 5Atmosfera 5

Thoroughly enjoyed a delicious meal in the restaurant section - which assured us of a great seat in the adjoining piano bar where the extremely talented pianist, Paddy, accompanied the wait staff who would break into song and/or take the mic after 9 pm. 'had an absolutely wonderful evening in NYC's theater district.

Segnala
Utile
IL
Atlantic City
2 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 12 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 5servizio 5Atmosfera 5

We went for the first time based off the recommendation of a friend and absolutely LOVED it. The ambiance was great, the food and drinks were delicious and then our dessert was phenomenal. We each ordered something different so we could taste the others (4 in all) especially the Chocolate Prada and we thoroughly enjoyed each of them. The cost was also reasonable for the quality we received.

Segnala
Utile
c
New York
166 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 11 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 4cibo 3servizio 4Atmosfera 4

We went to a cabaret performance and wanted to stay in same venue and the restaurant had a nice varied menu so we stayed and all was fine and convenient

Segnala
Utile
LS
1 recensione
Visitato il giorno 8 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 5servizio 5Atmosfera 5

Two of us stopped in pre theater in January. We had been here once before in the summer and every table was taken plus a long wait. This time we found it pleasantly uncrowded. The food was delicious and the service spot on. We were not rushed out at all (probably due to it being a slow night, but still we appreciated it). As native New Yorkers we feel we found a gem and would return again.

Segnala
Utile
SL
New York
26 recensioni
Visitato il giorno 6 gennaio 2019
Complessivo 5cibo 4servizio 5Atmosfera 5

I love Don't Tell Moma! It's the place place on Restaurant Row and love all the regular customers who have been coming back for years.

Segnala
Utile
1
2
3
41